Pathogen reduction co-benefits of nutrient best management practices
Background: Many of the practices currently underway to reduce nitrogen,
phosphorus, and sediment loads entering the Chesapeake Bay have also been
observed to support reduction of disease-causing pathogen loadings. We quantify how implementation of these practices, proposed to meet the nutrient and sediment caps prescribed by the Total Maximum Daily Load (TMDL), could reduce pathogen loadings and provide public health co-benefits within the Chesapeake Bay system.
Methods: We used published data on the pathogen reduction potential of
management practices and baseline fecal coliform loadings estimated as part of
prior modeling to estimate the reduction in pathogen loadings to the mainstem
Potomac River and Chesapeake Bay attributable to practices implemented as part
of the TMDL. We then compare the estimates with the baseline loadings of fecal
coliform loadings to estimate the total pathogen reduction potential of the TMDL.
Results: We estimate that the TMDL practices have the potential to decrease
disease-causing pathogen loads from all point and non-point sources to the
mainstem Potomac River and the entire Chesapeake Bay watershed by 19 and 27%,
respectively. These numbers are likely to be underestimates due to data limitations that forced us to omit some practices from analysis.
Discussion: Based on known impairments and disease incidence rates, we conclude that efforts to reduce nutrients may create substantial health co-benefits by
improving the safety of water-contact recreation and seafood consumption.