Evaluating the impact of uncertainties in clearance and exposure when prioritizing chemicals screened in high-throughput assays
Leonard, J. A., Leonard, A. S., Chang, D. T., Edwards, S., Lu, J., Scholle, S., ... Tan, Y-M. (2016). Evaluating the impact of uncertainties in clearance and exposure when prioritizing chemicals screened in high-throughput assays. Environmental Science & Technology, 50(11), 5961-5971. DOI: 10.1021/acs.est.6b00374
The toxicity-testing paradigm has evolved to include high throughput (HT) methods for addressing the increasing need to screen hundreds to thousands of chemicals rapidly. Approaches that involve in vitro screening assays, in silico predictions of exposure concentrations, and pharmacokinetic (PK) characteristics provide the foundation for HT risk prioritization. Underlying uncertainties in predicted exposure concentrations or PR behaviors can significantly influence the prioritization of chemicals, though the impact of such influences is unclear. In the current study, a framework was developed to incorporate absorbed doses, PR properties, and in vitro dose response data into a PK/pharmacodynamic (PD) model to allow for placement of chemicals into discrete priority bins. Literature-reported or predicted values for clearance rates and absorbed doses were used in the PK/PD model to evaluate the impact of their uncertainties on chemical prioritization. Scenarios using predicted absorbed doses resulted in a larger number of bin misassignments than those scenarios using predicted clearance rates, when comparing to bin placement using literature-reported values. Sensitivity of parameters on the model output of toxicological activity was examined across possible ranges for those parameters to provide insight into how uncertainty in their predicted values might impact uncertainty in activity.